I put up a post some months ago about a house on Queen Anne that was being redone. It was gutted down to the studs inside, and out.
http://seattlerealestatefixer.com/wp-admin/post.php?post=258&action=edit
The point was, to ask the question why some one would go to this expense rather than just jack the framing up. My conclusion was that they were trying to preserve the fire place, but today I saw the finished product. Holy Cow!
When you walk in you are walking up an incline to the middle of the house. On the right is the fire place with the window on the right tilted about a half of an inch, just enough to notice. In the middle of the house is a distinct hump.
I could go on for a long time about the odd feel of the property, but let me get to my real concern. The house has been turned into a triplex. Each floor has a kitchen, bath, and bedroom, or two. The floor issue is only one of a set of issues that I would have. Let’s say the owner has spent $120K, maybe less, but the work is extensive. Let’s say the purchase price was around $225K. Let’s say the whole project comes in at $325K, or maybe $100 per square foot, and will rent for $3600 a month. Let’s say it’s a brilliant move all the way around.
Now you still have the foundation that has settled 4 and 1/2 inches in the South East corner. So even if you are holding the property to reuse the dirt in the future, you still have a tear down. A bigger concern to me is that some one, or entity, has tied up that amount of money, for that long. Even if, over time, the property pays for itself, it’s funky.
Obviously this is a smarter person than I am, but still, if you’re going to have funky, why spend a bunch of money to do it? If you’re going to rework a property you should at least make the attempt to do it right. In this case it was a matter of about $5K, maybe $10K, but probably a lot less.